We offer free pickup at any of our store locations. For Delivery, call us about our shipping rates for more info!
Consumer Choice
Shop the Consumer Choice collection at Five Star Furniture & Mattress in Milledgeville, GA. This curated collection highlights top-rated furniture picks across living room, bedroom, dining room, and more — pieces recognized for their combination of quality construction, everyday value, and on-trend style. If you're looking for furniture that has been vetted for comfort, durability, and customer satisfaction, the Consumer Choice collection is a great place to start. Whether you're furnishing a new home or refreshing a single room, these selections make shopping easier by narrowing the field to proven favorites. Browse sofas, bedroom sets, dining tables, accent pieces, and more from the collection. Visit our furniture showroom in Milledgeville to see Consumer Choice pieces on display, or browse the full collection online. Our team is here to help you find the right pieces for your home. Delivery and flexible financing are available throughout the Milledgeville, GA area. Financing options available.
-
Save 23%
Original price $277.13Original price $277.13 - Original price $277.13Original price $277.13Current price $213.18$213.18 - $213.18Current price $213.18Valebeck Bar Height Bar Stool
Ashley FurnitureA touch of rustic-industrial style is such a fashion-forward choice, and this barstool doesn’t disappoint. Set this tall barstool by the kitchen ba...
View full detailsOriginal price $277.13Original price $277.13 - Original price $277.13Original price $277.13Current price $213.18$213.18 - $213.18Current price $213.18Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $575.59Original price $575.59 - Original price $575.59Original price $575.59Current price $442.76$442.76 - $442.76Current price $442.76Tyler Creek Sofa/Console Table
Ashley FurnitureShabby chic with a hint of down-home country, this sofa table is all the talk of today’s design world. Wood grain shows through the weathered gray-...
View full detailsOriginal price $575.59Original price $575.59 - Original price $575.59Original price $575.59Current price $442.76$442.76 - $442.76Current price $442.76Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $470.98Original price $470.98 - Original price $759.03Original price $470.98Current price $362.29$362.29 - $583.87Current price $362.29Tyler Creek End Table Set
Ashley FurnitureShabby chic with a hint of down home country. This 2-piece rectangular end table with textured black finish is all the talk of today’s design world...
View full detailsOriginal price $470.98Original price $470.98 - Original price $759.03Original price $470.98Current price $362.29$362.29 - $583.87Current price $362.29Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $379.52Original price $379.52 - Original price $379.52Original price $379.52Current price $291.94$291.94 - $291.94Current price $291.94Tyler Creek End Table
Ashley FurnitureShabby chic with a hint of down-home country, this rectangular end table is all the talk of today’s design world. Wood grain shows through the weat...
View full detailsOriginal price $379.52Original price $379.52 - Original price $379.52Original price $379.52Current price $291.94$291.94 - $291.94Current price $291.94Save 23% -
Save up to 23%
Original price $360.27 - Original price $587.51Original price $360.27 - Original price $587.51Original price $360.27$277.13 - $451.93$277.13 - $451.93Current price $277.13Tyler Creek Dining Chair Set
Ashley FurnitureInvite your family into the heart of your home with this upholstered dining room chair. Its slat back and tapered legs, in a beautifully textured b...
View full detailsOriginal price $360.27 - Original price $587.51Original price $360.27 - Original price $587.51Original price $360.27$277.13 - $451.93$277.13 - $451.93Current price $277.13Save up to 23% -
Save up to 23%
Original price $180.14 - Original price $293.76Original price $180.14 - Original price $293.76Original price $180.14$138.57 - $225.97$138.57 - $225.97Current price $138.57Tyler Creek Dining Chair
Ashley FurnitureInvite your family into the heart of your home with this upholstered dining room chair. Its slat back and tapered legs, in a beautifully textured b...
View full detailsOriginal price $180.14 - Original price $293.76Original price $180.14 - Original price $293.76Original price $180.14$138.57 - $225.97$138.57 - $225.97Current price $138.57Save up to 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $293.76Original price $293.76 - Original price $293.76Original price $293.76Current price $225.97$225.97 - $225.97Current price $225.97Tyler Creek Dining Bench
Ashley FurnitureInvite your family into the heart of your home with this upholstered dining room bench. Its X-shaped stretcher and tapered legs, in a beautifully t...
View full detailsOriginal price $293.76Original price $293.76 - Original price $293.76Original price $293.76Current price $225.97$225.97 - $225.97Current price $225.97Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $293.76Original price $293.76 - Original price $293.76Original price $293.76Current price $225.97$225.97 - $225.97Current price $225.97Tyler Creek Counter Height Dining Bench
Ashley FurnitureInvite your family into the heart of your home with this upholstered dining room bench. Its tapered legs provide a sturdy foundation, while the cou...
View full detailsOriginal price $293.76Original price $293.76 - Original price $293.76Original price $293.76Current price $225.97$225.97 - $225.97Current price $225.97Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $212.00Original price $212.00 - Original price $212.00Original price $212.00Current price $163.08$163.08 - $163.08Current price $163.08Tyler Creek Counter Height Bar Stool
Ashley FurnitureInvite your family into the heart of your home with this upholstered bar stool. Its framed back and tapered legs, in a beautifully textured black f...
View full detailsOriginal price $212.00Original price $212.00 - Original price $212.00Original price $212.00Current price $163.08$163.08 - $163.08Current price $163.08Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $350.47Original price $350.47 - Original price $350.47Original price $350.47Current price $269.59$269.59 - $269.59Current price $269.59Tyler Creek Chairside End Table with USB Ports & Outlets
Ashley FurnitureShabby chic with a hint of down-home country, this chairside end table is all the talk of today’s design world. Wood grain shows through the weathe...
View full detailsOriginal price $350.47Original price $350.47 - Original price $350.47Original price $350.47Current price $269.59$269.59 - $269.59Current price $269.59Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $235.50Original price $235.50 - Original price $235.50Original price $235.50Current price $181.15$181.15 - $181.15Current price $181.15Tyler Creek Chairside End Table
Ashley FurnitureQuality crafted and richly styled, this rectangular chairside end table is sure to charm. Its two-tone aesthetic pairs a weathered grayish brown ta...
View full detailsOriginal price $235.50Original price $235.50 - Original price $235.50Original price $235.50Current price $181.15$181.15 - $181.15Current price $181.15Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $424.00Original price $424.00 - Original price $424.00Original price $424.00Current price $326.15$326.15 - $326.15Current price $326.15Tyler Creek Bar Stool Set
Ashley FurnitureInvite your family into the heart of your home with this upholstered bar stool. Its framed back and tapered legs, in a beautifully textured black f...
View full detailsOriginal price $424.00Original price $424.00 - Original price $424.00Original price $424.00Current price $326.15$326.15 - $326.15Current price $326.15Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $628.94Original price $628.94 - Original price $628.94Original price $628.94Current price $483.80$483.80 - $483.80Current price $483.80Tulen Recliner
Ashley FurnitureThis rocker recliner puts the win in winning. Its waterfall back design and doubly plump pillow top arms team up with soft chenille fabric to go fo...
View full detailsOriginal price $628.94Original price $628.94 - Original price $628.94Original price $628.94Current price $483.80$483.80 - $483.80Current price $483.80Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $296.53Original price $296.53 - Original price $296.53Original price $296.53Current price $228.10$228.10 - $228.10Current price $228.10Trinell Youth Nightstand
Ashley FurnitureWhether she loves horses or he's a cowboy at heart, this nightstand matches their authenticity. Its rustic finish, plank-style details and nailhead...
View full detailsOriginal price $296.53Original price $296.53 - Original price $296.53Original price $296.53Current price $228.10$228.10 - $228.10Current price $228.10Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $533.49Original price $533.49 - Original price $533.49Original price $533.49Current price $410.38$410.38 - $410.38Current price $410.38Trinell Youth Chest of Drawers
Ashley FurnitureWhether she loves horses or he's a cowboy at heart, this chest of drawers matches their authenticity. Its rustic finish, plank-style details and na...
View full detailsOriginal price $533.49Original price $533.49 - Original price $533.49Original price $533.49Current price $410.38$410.38 - $410.38Current price $410.38Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $484.97Original price $484.97 - Original price $565.33Original price $484.97Current price $373.05$373.05 - $434.87Current price $373.05Trinell Youth Bed
Ashley FurnitureWhether she loves horses or he's a cowboy at heart, this full panel bed matches their authentic sense of style. Its rustic finish, plank details an...
View full detailsOriginal price $484.97Original price $484.97 - Original price $565.33Original price $484.97Current price $373.05$373.05 - $434.87Current price $373.05Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $165.79Original price $165.79 - Original price $382.46Original price $165.79Current price $127.53$127.53 - $294.20Current price $127.53Trinell Pier
Ashley FurnitureEntertain a rugged yet refined sense of style with this entertainment center pier. Its rustic finish and plank-style details pay homage to reclaime...
View full detailsOriginal price $165.79Original price $165.79 - Original price $382.46Original price $165.79Current price $127.53$127.53 - $294.20Current price $127.53Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $321.48Original price $321.48 - Original price $321.48Original price $321.48Current price $247.29$247.29 - $247.29Current price $247.29Trinell Nightstand
Ashley FurnitureWhether she loves horses or he's a cowboy at heart, this nightstand matches their authenticity. Its rustic finish, plank-style details and nailhead...
View full detailsOriginal price $321.48Original price $321.48 - Original price $321.48Original price $321.48Current price $247.29$247.29 - $247.29Current price $247.29Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $565.33Original price $565.33 - Original price $1,040.64Original price $565.33Current price $434.87$434.87 - $800.49Current price $434.87Trinell Bed
Ashley FurnitureGiddy up your style. If you’re a cowboy or cowgirl at heart, this king poster bed matches your authentic sense of taste. Its rustic finish, plank d...
View full detailsOriginal price $565.33Original price $565.33 - Original price $1,040.64Original price $565.33Current price $434.87$434.87 - $800.49Current price $434.87Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $469.74Original price $469.74 - Original price $469.74Original price $469.74Current price $361.34$361.34 - $361.34Current price $361.34Trinell 63" TV Stand
Ashley FurnitureThis TV stand with fireplace option makes your home on the range look so alluring. The aesthetic is earthy yet clean and sophisticated, paying homa...
View full detailsOriginal price $469.74Original price $469.74 - Original price $469.74Original price $469.74Current price $361.34$361.34 - $361.34Current price $361.34Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $643.79Original price $643.79 - Original price $1,326.12Original price $643.79Current price $495.22$495.22 - $1,020.09Current price $495.22Trinell 4-Piece Entertainment Center
Ashley FurnitureEntertain a rugged yet refined sense of style with this 4-piece entertainment center. Its rustic finish and plank-style details pay homage to recla...
View full detailsOriginal price $643.79Original price $643.79 - Original price $1,326.12Original price $643.79Current price $495.22$495.22 - $1,020.09Current price $495.22Save 23% -
Save up to 23%
Original price $551.82 - Original price $1,234.65Original price $551.82 - Original price $1,234.65Original price $551.82$424.48 - $949.73$424.48 - $949.73Current price $424.48Trinell 3-Piece Entertainment Center
Ashley FurnitureEntertain a rugged yet refined sense of style with this entertainment center. Its rustic finish and plank-style details pay homage to reclaimed bar...
View full detailsOriginal price $551.82 - Original price $1,234.65Original price $551.82 - Original price $1,234.65Original price $551.82$424.48 - $949.73$424.48 - $949.73Current price $424.48Save up to 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $243.96Original price $243.96 - Original price $243.96Original price $243.96Current price $187.66$187.66 - $187.66Current price $187.66Trailbend Accent Table
Ashley FurnitureFor those with discriminating tastes and a desire to be different, this two-tone accent table offers a unique conversation piece for contemporary d...
View full detailsOriginal price $243.96Original price $243.96 - Original price $243.96Original price $243.96Current price $187.66$187.66 - $187.66Current price $187.66Save 23% -
Save 23%
Original price $321.43Original price $321.43 - Original price $321.43Original price $321.43Current price $247.25$247.25 - $247.25Current price $247.25Todoe End Table with USB Ports & Outlets
Ashley FurnitureTake a stance for rustic-industrial style with this mixed material end table. Weather-washed pine wood and veneers are contrasted with canted metal...
View full detailsOriginal price $321.43Original price $321.43 - Original price $321.43Original price $321.43Current price $247.25$247.25 - $247.25Current price $247.25Save 23%
Pickup / Delivery
Consumer Choice — Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Consumer Choice collection?
Consumer Choice gathers the pieces our customers love most at Five Star Furniture & Mattress (GA) — the styles that get chosen, reviewed well, and reordered again and again. Think of it as a shortcut to our proven favorites.
Why should I shop Consumer Choice?
If you want something dependable without combing through the entire catalog, this is a great place to start — it's a curated shortlist of best-sellers from Ashley Furniture that have already won people over.
Do you deliver Consumer Choice items?
Yes. We deliver throughout our local service area — see our shipping & delivery policy for timelines and coverage, or contact us for a quote.
Can I finance a Consumer Choice purchase?
Yes. We offer financing options on qualifying purchases, often with promotional low- or no-interest plans.
Can I see these items in person?
Many of our most popular pieces are on display in the showroom, though the floor selection rotates. Please contact us to confirm a specific item is available to view before you visit.
What if my item arrives damaged?
Inspect it at delivery, note any damage on the paperwork, take photos, and contact us right away. We'll arrange a repair, replacement, or return under our return policy.